lunes, 28 de febrero de 2011

“On S’Embrasse?” Review






This outstanding short film directed by Pierre Olivier
 concisely presents two characters to the audience who live a brief encounter created by fate, portraying in a well-achieved way their reactions.

The film begins with a woman (Alice Carel) entering a coffee shop and reading a paper. The following shot shows a solitaire man (Jean-Luc Abel) 
in an empty table. As the woman approaches the man she asks him if he could help her run lines for a movie she is auditioning for in a short while. As the actress sits down, the director employs consecutive close-ups of both characters as they read.

As the woman starts to recite her lines, there is obvious tension between the characters, but as they continue reading, the tension slowly fades. Olivier is able to depict these as he continues to employ wonderful close-ups of both characters, which get closer in every take. As the two characters read the story two consecutive times, the man suggests the woman to recite her lines in a different way, smiling, as well as the final question, on s’embrasse? (shall we kiss?) As she does so, the audience realises, at the same time than the actress that the man has been dumped recently, and tears begin to descend form her eyes, arriving to the climax of the story.

Thanking the man for his help, and apologising for any inconvenience, the woman abandons the coffee store and, after a close-up of the man, a second woman emerges from the bathroom and, just like in the script he had read before, announces she is leaving and asks if they should kiss (on s’embrasse).

In conclusion, this extraordinary  short film gives a final turn and surprises the audience with the final question, making the audience aware that the story narrated in the first woman’s script is the real situation of the man in the coffee store. However, Olivier decides that the character does not answer the final question, finalising the film with an open ending.


I believe this is a great short film and rate it with ****

2 comentarios:

  1. Well done, Belén. An excellent first review and I’m delighted that you enjoyed this short.

    Done forget about themes, or ‘what questions does the film ask?’: this short asks us questions about truth, about real and imagined emotions, and about whether dramatic realism is the same as the reality of our experience. You should also consider an answer to the following question: why does the actress start to cry? What has she realised?

    ResponderEliminar
  2. Well this might have just gone over my head. I understood (the second time) that the script was the real situation for the man but why does his wife (presumably) at the end say can we kiss?

    ResponderEliminar